SEASIDE, CA – Monterey County Weekly today published a 10,000-plus word
investigative report “True Confessions,†which tracks an alleged sexual abuse scandal
within the Diocese of Monterey and the church’s attempt to keep the real story from the public.
The backstory: In 2011 a former parishioner sued the diocese for alleged sexual
molestation by Father Fitz-Henry dating back to 2005 when John “RJ” Doe was fifteen
years-old. The Church settled with Doe for $500,000, and sought to keep its internal
investigation of the priest sealed and out of the public’s view. In a cross-complaint, the
diocese also settled a lawsuit filed by Father Fitz-Henry, which resulted in his leaving the
church ministry.
Monterey County Weekly filed a motion in 2013 to have the documents unsealed and
ultimately prevailed in a unanimous 3-0 vote by the state Court of Appeal in July,
affirming the lower court decision allowing the documents to be disclosed. The Weekly
subsequently received nearly 1,350 pages of court documents, including depositions
and correspondence.
“True Confessions” reveals that the Diocese’s own investigator believed there may have
been up to six alleged victims, that a whistleblower was told to mind her own business,
that Father Fitz-Henry’s attorney “begged†the church not to settle with John Doe, and
finally, in his first interview since the charges were made, the former priest maintains
his innocence.
“True Confessions†was written by Weekly editor Mary Duan and assistant editor Sara
Rubin, is a Special Report — following this multi-year court battle — revealing what the
diocese knew, when they knew it and what they did about it.
Monterey County Weekly was represented in its legal battle by Roger Myers of Bryan
Cave, San Francisco. The complete Special Report is also available online, including the
full Q & A with Father Fitz-Henry. http://www.mcweekly.com/FitzHenry
Contact: Mary Duan, Editor (831) 394-5656 x 107; Bradley Zeve, Founder & CEO, (831)
601-5678; Erik Cushman, Publisher (831) 2394-5656 x125; Roger Myers (415) 328-9654